Replacement Bathtubs for Greater Milwaukee Homes
A New Bathtub Without Reworking Your Entire Bathroom
A bathtub replacement can make a bigger difference than you might expect. A stained surface, outdated design, or tub that's difficult to keep clean can make an otherwise functional bathroom feel past its prime.
Exterior Pros installs BCI Acrylic replacement bathtubs for homeowners throughout Greater Milwaukee. Our bath systems provide a fresh, low-maintenance bathing space without the disruption of a complete bathroom remodel.
Our in-house bath crews complete every replacement using custom-fitted BCI Acrylic systems. You get a new bathtub built for your space, backed by a BCI Acrylic Lifetime Warranty and Exterior Pros' 10-year workmanship warranty.
BCI Acrylic Bathtubs Built for Everyday Use
We install BCI Acrylic bath systems because they’re designed for the way homeowners actually use their bathrooms. The nonporous acrylic surface helps resist moisture buildup, mold, and mildew while making routine cleaning easier. Unlike tile-based systems, BCI Acrylic products do not require grout maintenance, giving you a simpler surface to care for over time.
Each bathtub replacement is custom-fitted to your existing space, resulting in a finished bath area that looks intentional and functions as it should. BCI Acrylic products are also available with accessibility considerations, including ADA-compliant configurations for homeowners who need additional safety features.
Milwaukee’s Most Trusted Replacement Bathtubs
Our acrylic bathtubs from BCI Acrylic are considered by many to be the strongest, most durable bathtubs on the market. Plus, they offer a range of replacement bathtub types to ensure your EXACT need is met.
Shower & Tub Combos
Sometimes you need versatility and the ability to take a shower or a bath when you need it. That’s what makes shower and tub combos great. They are:
✔ Great For Families
✔ Ideal For Small Bathrooms
✔ Easily Customizable To Fit Your Needs
Walk-In Tubs
If you need a safer bathtub to reduce the risk of slips, falls, or tripping, a walk-in tub is a great solution. Here’s what’s possible with BCI Acrylic walk-in tubs.
✔ Low-Step Thresholds
✔ Comfy & Cozy Built-In Seating
✔ Whirlpool Jets & Therapy Systems
Easy-Access Tubs
If a standard walk-in tub isn’t enough and you want added safety and accessibility features, we can do that, too. Here’s what’s possible with our easy-access bathtubs:
✔ Wider Entries
✔ Non-Slip Flooring
✔ Grab Bars & Hand Rails
Other Bath Options to Consider
Not sure a replacement bathtub is the right fit? We can help you explore other ways to update your bathing space. If you would rather have a shower, our tub-to-shower conversions replace your existing tub with a walk-in shower designed for your bathroom. If you currently have a shower but miss having a bathtub, our shower-to-tub conversions can give you that option without reworking the entire room.
Why Homeowners Replace Their Bathtubs
Not every bathroom needs a full renovation to feel new again. Sometimes replacing the bathtub is the update that makes the biggest difference.
Homeowners often choose bathtub replacement when they want to:
Replace a worn-out tub: Remove stains, cracks, discoloration, or outdated surfaces that are difficult to maintain.
Improve everyday comfort: Upgrade to a cleaner, more functional bathtub that better fits your routine.
Update the look of the bathroom: Refresh the bathing area without changing the entire layout.
Plan for future needs: Choose accessible options that make the bathroom easier to use over time.
Whatever your reason for replacing the tub, Exterior Pros can help you find the right setup for your home.
Backed by Product and Installation Warranties
A bathtub replacement is an investment in your home, which is why warranty coverage matters. BCI Acrylic provides a lifetime warranty that covers the bathtub surface against fading, discoloring, cracking, bubbling, and peeling for as long as you own and live in the home. If you sell your home within two years of installation, qualifying warranty coverage can transfer to the next homeowner.
Exterior Pros also provides a 10-year workmanship warranty on qualifying installations. The product warranty protects your bathtub system, while our workmanship warranty backs the installation itself. For complete details, visit our warranties page.
What to Expect During Bathtub Replacement
Bathtub replacement with Exterior Pros means replacing the old system rather than resurfacing or refinishing it. Our in-house bath crew manages the installation from removal through completion.
Here's what you can expect:
Remove the Existing Tub
We remove the old bathtub and any necessary surrounding materials.
Prepare the Space
Our crew evaluates and prepares the exposed area for the new bath system.
Install the New Bathtub
We install your BCI Acrylic bathtub according to manufacturer requirements.
Complete the Finishing Work
The crew checks the installation, completes the final details, and cleans the work area.
A dedicated project manager stays connected throughout the project, giving you a clear point of contact along the way.
What to Expect From Exterior Pros
Choosing the right bathtub is only part of the project. The installation experience matters too. Exterior Pros uses in-house bath crews rather than outside subcontractors for our bath installations. We also assign a dedicated project manager, giving you a consistent point of contact throughout the process.
Your project starts with a free estimate, where we'll review your existing bathroom, discuss your goals, and explain your options. Once you receive your estimate, your pricing remains valid for a full year, giving you time to decide.
If financing would make your project easier to plan, our lending partners offer options for qualifying homeowners. Learn more on our financing page.
Why Greater Milwaukee Homeowners Choose Exterior Pros
Exterior Pros has helped homeowners throughout Greater Milwaukee update their homes since 2012. Founder Sheila Hibl started the company after seeing how difficult it could be to find reliable contractors whom homeowners could trust. Today, that customer-first mindset continues to guide every project.
Homeowners choose Exterior Pros for:
100% woman-owned, family-operated leadership
In-house bath installation crews
Dedicated project managers
Premium products from trusted manufacturers
Free estimates with pricing valid for one year
A+ Better Business Bureau rating maintained for more than a decade
10 Angi Super Service Awards
You can read more about our story, see customer feedback, or explore our full list of awards and accolades.
Replacement Bathtubs Throughout Greater Milwaukee
Exterior Pros is based in Sussex and installs replacement bathtubs throughout Greater Milwaukee and Southeast Wisconsin. We regularly serve homeowners in communities including Brookfield, Menomonee Falls, Waukesha, New Berlin, Pewaukee, Elm Grove, Delafield, Wauwatosa, Muskego, Oconomowoc, Franklin, and surrounding areas.
Frequently Asked Questions About Bathtub Replacement
The timeline depends on your specific project and bathroom setup. During your estimate, we can discuss what to expect based on your existing space and the bathtub system you choose.
We install BCI Acrylic replacement bathtub systems. These custom-fitted acrylic systems are designed for durability, easy maintenance, and long-term performance.
Yes. A bathtub replacement focuses on updating the bathing area, letting you improve one of the most-used parts of your bathroom without a full renovation.
Yes. BCI Acrylic provides a Lifetime Warranty covering the bathtub surface, and Exterior Pros provides a 10-year workmanship warranty on qualifying installations.
Yes. Exterior Pros offers walk-in tubs and easy-access bath options for homeowners who want additional safety and accessibility features.
Get Your Free Bathtub Replacement Estimate in Greater Milwaukee
If your bathtub is outdated, difficult to maintain, or simply no longer fits your needs, Exterior Pros can help you replace it with a durable BCI Acrylic system designed for your home. Request your free estimate today and get pricing that stays valid for a full year.
Our Baths Project Gallery
What You Can Expect From Exterior Pros
Exterior Pros was built around a simple idea: homeowners should not have to chase down their contractor for answers or wonder whether corners were cut after the project is finished.
That customer-first approach shows up in practical ways throughout your project:
A dedicated project manager
You have a specific point of contact who can answer questions and keep you informed.
Professional crews
Our window and bath installations are completed by full-time crews who work with these products every day.
You can learn more about the standards behind our first-class care and no cut corners approach, or visit Why Us for a closer look at what makes our team different.
0% Interest Financing Available
Exterior Pros offers flexible financing options to make funding your home improvement project easier. We’ll help connect you with our trusted lending partners who offer an easy application and fast approvals. Plus, they offer ZERO interest options if paid in full within 12 months.
See What Greater Milwaukee Customers Are Saying About Our Home Remodeling Services
“They were really helpful and made sure that we were getting the product. They had to custom make our door and they did custom trim work to make sure that everything fits and seals properly. From sales to installation the entire company was helpful and took care of our concerns.”
Melissa J
“Exterior Pros is an Excellent Company to work with! Highly recommend!! Stress free from start to finish. Storm door and window turned out better than we could have imagined. Will definitely use them in the future.”
Nicole S.
“The very helpful staff at Exterior Pros who answered all my questions and gave great ideas when choosing a new patio door as well as storm door. quickly returned all my calls with questions.”
Karen S.
“Working with Exterior Pros was incredibly easy. They never did anything that made me feel less than or stupid, like other companies have. When it came to knowledge of the windows, they were very educational and easy to get in touch with. Their technicians were super helpful, friendly, and knowledgeable.”
Jason R.
“I applaud Exterior Pros for a window job well done! All of our main and second floor windows were replaced at a reasonable price and have enhanced the curb appeal of our home as well as the heating and cooling costs. Thank you Juan, for putting together a great package.”
Sam W.
“If you're looking for a roofer who truly cares about the job, look no further than this family-owned business in Sussex, WI. They take great pride in their work and value each customer. They specialize in providing custom roofing solutions tailored to your unique needs.”
Payton T.
“We love our 22 updated windows ! Note the Prairie Style border we added to front of the home windows. No more bugs sneaking in nor bees through the one rotting window ledge. The guys were awesome and impeccable.”
Penny C.
“Exterior Pros did a great job on my house. They replaced the siding 2 years ago and now replaced the fascia and soffits and a portion of the gutter and gutter guard. They also tore off a wooden awning that was over my patio. The awning was rotting.”
Marcia B.
Contact Us
Mon - Fri: 8:00am - 8:00pm
Sat: 9:00am - 5:00pm
Sun: Closed