Shower-to-Tub Conversions in Greater Milwaukee, WI
Turn an Existing Shower Into a Bathtub That Better Fits Your Home
Not every household wants a shower-only bathroom. Maybe you have young children, miss having a place to soak, or simply want a bathtub back in a space that was converted years ago. A shower-to-tub conversion gives you that option without turning the entire bathroom into a major construction project.
Exterior Pros installs BCI Acrylic bathtub systems for homeowners throughout Greater Milwaukee and Southeast Wisconsin. We remove the existing shower and replace it with a new bathtub system built for the space, giving you a fresh bathing area rather than covering up what’s already there.
If your bathroom would work better with a tub, we can help you figure out what makes sense for the space.
Our Shower-To-Tub Conversion Process
Removing your existing shower and installing a beautiful, brand-new bathtub may seem like a daunting task, but we make it (look) easy. It includes three primary steps.
1st Step - The Consultation Process
Your shower-to-tub conversion begins with a consultation visit to discuss and discover your goals and vision. We’ll answer your questions and give you a 100% accurate quote.
2nd Step - Shower Removal
We will completely and thoroughly remove your existing shower space. We’ll go down to the studs and address any underlying concerns that may put the long-term durability of your new bath at risk.
3rd Step - Bathtub Installation
Lastly, we’ll install your beautiful new bathtub with impeccable craftsmanship on the first try. We never cut corners, skip steps, or rush to finish the job faster than we should to ensure a quality result.
When Does a Shower-to-Tub Conversion Make Sense?
There’s no single reason homeowners decide to bring a bathtub back. Often, it simply comes down to how the bathroom is being used now compared with when the shower was installed.
A conversion may make sense if:
You have young children: A bathtub can make everyday bathing routines much easier for families.
You prefer baths: If soaking is part of how you like to relax, a shower-only bathroom may always feel like it’s missing something.
Your shower is outdated: Replacing an aging shower is an opportunity to rethink whether you still want the same setup.
You want more bathing options: Adding a tub gives household members and future homeowners the choice between bathing and showering.
Benefits Of Our Milwaukee, WI, Shower-To-Tub Conversions
Whether you’re looking for a place to soak, a safer experience, or a more family-friendly setup, our shower-to-tub conversions deliver practical benefits you’ll enjoy.
Increased Safety
If you want your new bathtub to be a walk-in model, you will enjoy a low-entry threshold, built-in seating, and grab bars that drastically reduce the risk of slips and falls. This is perfect for older adults or individuals who have more limited mobility.
Added Comfort
At the end of a long, hard day, you just want a nice, cozy bath with plenty of space to unwind and relax. Our tubs are designed and constructed for an enhanced soaking experience. It will feel like your very own personal spa… because it will be!
Great For Children
It’s typically recommended that children not shower on their own until they’re five to seven years old. If you have children under this age, you may need to convert your shower space into a dependable bathtub that makes bath time easier and safer.
Easy Long-Term Maintenance
Our BCI Acrylic tubs are made from high-quality acrylic. They’re non-porous, stain-resistant, and grout-free. That means no mold, no mildew, and minimal cleaning. Just a quick wipe-down is all it takes to keep your new bathtub looking brand-new for years.
What Happens During a Shower-to-Tub Conversion?
A shower-to-tub conversion from Exterior Pros involves a full replacement, not a repair, coating, or surface update. We remove the existing shower components and install a new BCI Acrylic bathtub system designed for the available space.
That means you’re starting with a new bathing system rather than putting a new finish over an older fixture. Because these systems are designed for residential bath spaces, you can meaningfully change how the room functions without committing to a full bathroom renovation.
BCI Acrylic Bathtubs Made for Everyday Use
Your bathtub should be comfortable to use without becoming another high-maintenance surface in the house. That is one reason we install BCI Acrylic systems for our bath replacement projects.
The nonporous acrylic surface is designed to resist fading, discoloration, cracking, bubbling, and peeling under normal use. It is also easy to clean, which makes maintaining the bathing area much easier than dealing with worn or deteriorating surfaces.
BCI Acrylic backs its bath systems with a lifetime warranty for as long as you own and live in the home. If you sell the home within two years of installation, qualifying warranty coverage can transfer to the new homeowner.
We add another layer of protection with our own 10-year workmanship warranty. Learn more about both product and installation coverage on our warranties page.
What It's Like to Work With Exterior Pros
Changing your bathroom shouldn't mean wondering who is showing up or who to call with questions. Exterior Pros uses in-house bath crews and assigns a dedicated project manager to your project, giving you a consistent point of contact throughout the process. Our team focuses on complete replacement work and follows manufacturer requirements rather than relying on short-term fixes.
We also give you room to decide on your schedule. Your estimate is free, and the quoted pricing remains valid for a full year. If spreading the project cost out would be helpful, financing is available through our lending partners.
More Ways to Update Your Bath
A bathtub is not the right answer for every bathroom. If you are still deciding what would work best for your household, Exterior Pros offers several other full bath replacement options.
Tub-to-Shower Conversions: Ready to go in the opposite direction? Our tub-to-shower conversions replace an existing bathtub with a shower for homeowners who want easier entry or more open shower space.
Replacement Bathtubs: If you already have a bathtub and simply want a new one, our replacement bathtubs give you a fresh BCI Acrylic system without changing the basic function of the bathroom.
Replacement Showers: Homeowners who want to keep a shower-only layout can explore our replacement showers for a complete update to the existing shower space.
Easy-Access Bathrooms: If safety or mobility is becoming a bigger consideration, our easy-access bathrooms include options designed around accessibility and aging in place.
Why Greater Milwaukee Homeowners Choose Exterior Pros
Exterior Pros has been remodeling Greater Milwaukee homes since 2012, when founder Sheila Hibl created the company after seeing firsthand how difficult it could be for homeowners to find contractors they could depend on.
Our customer-first approach still guides the way we work today. Our company is 100% woman-owned and family-operated, with a local team based in Sussex.
Homeowners also choose us for:
In-house bath installation crews
Dedicated project managers
BCI Acrylic bath systems
10-year workmanship warranty
Free estimates with pricing good for one year
Financing options through trusted lending partners
A+ Better Business Bureau rating maintained for more than a decade
10 Angi Super Service Awards
Want to hear from homeowners who have already worked with us? Visit our reviews page.
Shower-to-Tub Conversions Across Greater Milwaukee
Exterior Pros is based in Sussex and serves homeowners throughout the Milwaukee Metro, Milwaukee suburbs, and Southeast Wisconsin.
Our service area includes communities such as Brookfield, Menomonee Falls, Waukesha, New Berlin, Pewaukee, Hartland, Delafield, Elm Grove, Wauwatosa, Muskego, Franklin, and many surrounding areas.
If you’re not sure whether we work in your neighborhood, visit our service areas page for more information.
Common Questions About Shower-to-Tub Conversions
Yes. Exterior Pros performs full replacements rather than bath repairs or surface treatments. We remove the existing shower components and install a new BCI Acrylic bathtub system in their place.
Not necessarily. A shower-to-tub conversion focuses on replacing the existing bathing area, so you can change how that part of the bathroom functions without automatically reworking the entire room.
BCI Acrylic offers a lifetime warranty covering the surface against fading, discoloration, cracking, bubbling, and peeling under normal use for as long as you own and live in the home. Exterior Pros also backs qualifying projects with a 10-year workmanship warranty.
If you sell your home within two years of installation, qualifying BCI Acrylic warranty coverage can be transferred to the new homeowner.
Pricing depends on the bathroom and the system you select, so Exterior Pros does not use a one-size-fits-all price. We provide a free estimate for your specific project, and that quoted pricing stays valid for a full year.
Yes. We offer bath configurations that can accommodate accessibility needs. If safer entry and easier bathing are your priorities, an easy-access bathroom or another accessible bath configuration may be a better fit than a standard bathtub.
Bring a Bathtub Back to Your Bathroom
If your shower-only bathroom no longer fits the way your household lives, a shower-to-tub conversion can give you back the comfort and flexibility your family needs. We’ll look at your existing space, talk through your options, and provide a free estimate with pricing that stays good for a full year. Contact Exterior Pros Wisconsin today to schedule your free estimate.
Our Baths Project Gallery
What You Can Expect From Exterior Pros
Exterior Pros was built around a simple idea: homeowners should not have to chase down their contractor for answers or wonder whether corners were cut after the project is finished.
That customer-first approach shows up in practical ways throughout your project:
A dedicated project manager
You have a specific point of contact who can answer questions and keep you informed.
Professional crews
Our window and bath installations are completed by full-time crews who work with these products every day.
You can learn more about the standards behind our first-class care and no cut corners approach, or visit Why Us for a closer look at what makes our team different.
0% Interest Financing Available
Exterior Pros offers flexible financing options to make funding your home improvement project easier. We’ll help connect you with our trusted lending partners who offer an easy application and fast approvals. Plus, they offer ZERO interest options if paid in full within 12 months.
See What Greater Milwaukee Customers Are Saying About Our Home Remodeling Services
“They were really helpful and made sure that we were getting the product. They had to custom make our door and they did custom trim work to make sure that everything fits and seals properly. From sales to installation the entire company was helpful and took care of our concerns.”
Melissa J
“Exterior Pros is an Excellent Company to work with! Highly recommend!! Stress free from start to finish. Storm door and window turned out better than we could have imagined. Will definitely use them in the future.”
Nicole S.
“The very helpful staff at Exterior Pros who answered all my questions and gave great ideas when choosing a new patio door as well as storm door. quickly returned all my calls with questions.”
Karen S.
“Working with Exterior Pros was incredibly easy. They never did anything that made me feel less than or stupid, like other companies have. When it came to knowledge of the windows, they were very educational and easy to get in touch with. Their technicians were super helpful, friendly, and knowledgeable.”
Jason R.
“I applaud Exterior Pros for a window job well done! All of our main and second floor windows were replaced at a reasonable price and have enhanced the curb appeal of our home as well as the heating and cooling costs. Thank you Juan, for putting together a great package.”
Sam W.
“If you're looking for a roofer who truly cares about the job, look no further than this family-owned business in Sussex, WI. They take great pride in their work and value each customer. They specialize in providing custom roofing solutions tailored to your unique needs.”
Payton T.
“We love our 22 updated windows ! Note the Prairie Style border we added to front of the home windows. No more bugs sneaking in nor bees through the one rotting window ledge. The guys were awesome and impeccable.”
Penny C.
“Exterior Pros did a great job on my house. They replaced the siding 2 years ago and now replaced the fascia and soffits and a portion of the gutter and gutter guard. They also tore off a wooden awning that was over my patio. The awning was rotting.”
Marcia B.
Contact Us
Mon - Fri: 8:00am - 8:00pm
Sat: 9:00am - 5:00pm
Sun: Closed